Search results

I really liked Star Trek Continues. It was definitely an improvement on Discovery.

Yeah, that episode is pretty uncomfortable viewing at the best of times. But watching someone see it for the first time is even more so.

Except it's not the only one. As I've already pointed out JMS has approved other viewing orders.

b5historyman is basically arguing that his interpretation for why there was controversy is the only possible one. I've never let anyone get away with that kind of nonsense whether it's about a TV show or not. Keeping an open mind and seeing that there might be other points of view is important.

No. You claim that is the controversy based on zero evidence because it fits your interpretation. I've pointed out an alternative and you're just ignoring it because you want to claim you're correct. Fine, if you want to continue to argue that you've found the one true list, you can do so. I...

While I don't disagree with you Looney, I don't have a problem with moving away from the airing order if the episodes were already filmed and then external issues forced a change in the order. That's more like the "premature death of the author". I tend to feel that is a fair order to let new...

Yep. It's just that I tend to post over on that board rather than on here. And yes, watching Mark watch the first 6 episodes of season 4 was as amazing as you'd expect. Especially the confused WTFs when the war was suddenly over.

I don't see how that backs up anything you said. In fact it actually undermines your point. If Mars is still part of the Earth Alliance that means that the Narn setting up a consulate there could be controversial even after they have independence. JMS doesn't seem to disagree that Mars being...

I disagree. I don't think another race would have made that station. Hell, the other races had space travel for hundreds or even thousands of years, if you're right, B5 should already have existed in the form of someone else's station with humans simply one delegate amongst many.

Really? This show is actually pretty good about showing off this point. Look at the main cast. Garibaldi is shown as being good friends with Londo and then G'Kar. Vir even goes to Ivanova for advice on women. And Delenn does the same for hairdressing tips. Throughout the show we see the...

Well I have seen the commenters on Mark Watches make some fairly major errors. What's really annoying is when you can't correct them because it's spoilers to explain. I'm literally waiting for War Without End II to play so I can take down some major misconceptions about Delenn.

I'm pretty sure that Legacies only mentions that the war started due to an accident. In fact they even see the Minbari coming in with their gun ports open as a sign of hostility and power up the defence grid (Which makes it seem like Sinclair and Garibaldi might not even know how the war...

Ah, the War Without End videos were a joy to watch. He was so happy to see Sinclair back at first and then just watching him realise how all the stuff he'd seen two seasons back slots into place in this one.

I was referring to G'Kar's eye and the time he left it on the shelf when Sheridan and Delenn get married in Deconstruction of Falling Stars.

The conversation I want to see is the one where he bought her lingerie and she hesitated about wearing it. Oh to have an electronic eye on the shelf for that one.

"You had a piece of the Black Star in our quarters and didn't tell me!" "You started the war and didn't tell me, fair's fair."

The Severed Dreams video was great. So much going on in that episode.

What's interesting is how wrong he is at the same time. I suspect he still thinks the Shadow War will end somewhere in Season 5. It's amazing how wrong almost everyone is about that the first time they watch the show.

One thing this rewatch is really highlighting is how fucked up Babylon 5 is. In the last six episodes we have seen - A character forced to keep a secret that results in several planets being enslaved. - An entire race get wiped out by plague. - A main character have her complete personality...

Nice site. But something should happen if you try to use peekaboo as the password. :p