I love Franke's B5 music, but I've always said that on the whole I prefer the synth sound from season 1 which sounds more spacey to me rather than the sampled orchestra that was most noticeable to me in season 5 and In the Beginning. Although one of the things that really bugs me about modern day film scores is the amount of big budget movies that feature sampled, fake orchestra (Hans Zimmer, Lorne Balfe and buddies, I'm looking at you) when they could easily afford the London Symphony Orchestra or something like that, on B5 they probably didn't have the budget for a big orchestra (no offense, Berlin Symphonic Film Orchestra).
Actually, it was like the Dresden orchestra, or something like that, wasn't it? Eastern Europe had lots of orchestras that played for tips practically right after the Cold War ended.
But yeah, I don't get the synthestra thing for major movies and stuff. TV, sure. Budget. Films? No. I'm no fan of Zimmer. I like Elfman quite a bit, though.
Look at TNG – their music is so sparsely composed it sounds like they could only afford handful of players in their orchestras.
Now that's a weird thing. I remember back in the day thinking "Why the heck aren't they using any incidental music?" and wondering why it was so bland when they did. It turns out that Berman and Pillar just basically didn't want big lush scores. Dunno why, maybe they thought it was corny, or whatever. In any event, there was a standing order to UNDERscore the show. In the 5th and 6th seasons, there were evidently some pretty heated arguments over this. This is all per conversations I've had on the Larry Niven List. There's a bunch of people over there that know a lot of BTS stuff about TNG.
As for leitmotif - perhaps. I think the station kind of had its own theme, based on the season 1 main titles, that would crop up from time to time like a fanfare, but as far as themes and leitmotif go, would they have got a bit tiring across 110 episodes? John Williams does leitmotif to a tee, but I'm not sure leitmotif is necessarily a requirement of a good score.
Oh, it's not. I agree. It doesn't fit all situations. But in the case of B5, with the music being so....ehm....standard for most of the run, it would have been nice to have at least a few more recognizable themes to hang the action on, you know? And I do trust Franke to have been able to evolve the themes over the run of the show the same way he evolved the main theme over the years. In any event, I feel the soundtrack needed more variation than it ended up having. Where do you stand?
In fact, genuine question, are there any TV scores that have used leitmotif? Have they been successful?
TOS did a simplified version. You had the fanfare, the ascending cliffhanger, the "I'm gonna' kick your ass" fight music, and the spock theme, all in a number of variations. The new Dr. Who has a full orchestra, and a number of dedicated themes, including a different personal theme for each doctor, one for each companion, etc. That works really well, and it's pretty successful. The new Galactica seemingly only had one piece of music during most of its first season, but then starting around "The Hand of God" they introduced a pretty little celtic piece called "A good lighter." That eventually became the Adama Family Theme, and there were a couple others. Most notably, though, there was the Adama theme, that damn Cylon music box piece, and the "Final Five" theme (including "All along the watchtower.")
I know you asked this of Ubik, but just to throw my own two-penneth in, personally I really like his theme for Defiance, and his score to Europa Report is just great, but aside from All Along the Watchtower, nothing stands out from his BSG scores for me except for what seemed like lots of militaristic percussion and not a lot of melody or powerful themes. There certainly wasn't anything to me that really tugged on the heart strings like Franke's music could.
The initial music was, I think, done by Richard Gibbs (Of Oingo Boingo), who basically only had one piece of music. He got fired for that. (He also got fired from The Simpsons for pretty much the same thing) Bear came in towards the end of season 1 (As I understand it) and introduced a much more elaborate fusion of different elements (Japanese drums, celtic strings, twangy electric guitars, etc) I thought it grew as it went along, and by the end it was quite literally the only thing I still liked about the show.
If you get a chance to listen to the soundtrack for the final season (2 CDs), give it a shot. It's lovely. In fact...[time passes]...nuts. I was trying to find the whole soundtrack on youtube or something. I couldn't. Ah well.
Here's an individual piece I like, though: it's a variation on the "Final Five" stuff
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_IsptRrIak
(ANd just to bring this conversation full-circle, that's Steve Bartek of Oingo Boingo on guitar)