Re: B5 S3 DVD Review over at Ain\'t It Cool
I really hate AICN as well. I can't stand Hercules, who I swear is the alter-ego of Joss Whedon's publicist.
Harry Knowles is a shamless self-promoter.
However, there was a time a few years ago when there was a guy named Glenn (I forget his last name) who went by the moniker Glenn (fill in last name here) who was a huge B5 fan. He gave great reviews in the "Coaxial News" (TV) for all B5 episodes. Back in the day, AICN was actually a good time, getting scoops, and stirring things up in the movie and television realms... a tiny bit. I only check it now, out of a) "car crash interest", and b) seeing them quoting TV-Guide and calling it a scoop.
A few years back, when Glenn was running the TV news, it wasn't basically a guy (Hercules, as he calls himself) who wanted to have Joss Whedon's children. I enjoyed Buffy, I like Angel, but I will NEVER put them in the same league as B5, DS9, Jeremiah, or anything on HBO. Joss realized he had a cult following, and unlike the X-Files, he turned his "episode of the week" into an arc-based serial sci-fi/fantasy series very well. That doesn't mean as a critic that everything he does is great.
Firefly, a sore-spot here, because of the news of a feature film... well, it sucked.
The writers at AICN give it a blank check.
Its gone far south, but AICN once server a purpose. It still gets an amazingly high amount of traffic, despite the fact its still powered by a CGI-app, has a horrible design, and every!!! single!!! headline!!! has!!! exclamation!!! points!!!
'nuff said.
-Tim