<font color=orange>Well, my post to rastb5m was disallowed because it contained "Story Ideas." Here was my response:</font color=orange>
How could my post below be considered as containing story ideas? "To Live
and Die in Starlight" is already water under the bridge. To disallow
comments of what would have made it better, *after* it was aired, would be
like saying that nobody could say that they should have eliminated the "zoo"
scene from "The Gathering" before the TNT version of it was made. What are
the odds that TLaDiS will ever get remade? About 0%. To be a story idea,
TLaDiS would have to be remade. If this is to be the restriction on story
ideas, then nobody should be able to say how any episode of B5 or Crusade
could have been made better, i.e. no suggestions for elimination of scenes
or addition of scenes, because there's always the possibility that they
could be remade in the future.
Still, I understand if you think that JMS seeing this post jeopardizes the
possible future of Legend of the Rangers, you should NOT let the post
through. I wouldn't want to jeopardize the future of Legend of the Rangers,
either. The trouble is that without seeing criticism, he's going to keep
falling into the traps he did with TLaDiS. I just wish there was a release
form we could sign to get past this story idea silliness and legal BS. What
we have here is a Catch-22.
KoshN
------------------------
http://www.scifi.com/crusade/ http://www.b5lr.com/
"Nothing much good on TV tonight anyway." (Captain Gideon, Babylon 5
Crusade - The Memory of War)
----- Original Message -----
From: <b5mod-request@deepthot.org>
Newsgroups: rec.arts.sf.tv.babylon5.moderated
Sent: Friday, May 24, 2002 1:57 PM
Subject: To Live and Die in Starlight - 5/24 Discussion from Another Group
> Your post to the rec.arts.sf.tv.babylon5.moderated newsgroup has
> not been accepted, as the moderators find it to contain a "Story Idea".
> Under current copyright law, the publication of copyrightable
> proposals concerning the future course of an ongoing television
> series places the creators of the series at particular legal
> risk, which we here consider to be a Bad Thing. Therefore, as
> a courtesy to the executive producer of Babylon 5 and others,
> "Story Ideas" are explicitly prohibited by the charter of this
> group.
>
> If your post was not intended to propose a story idea, but merely
> to speculate on the future direction of the series, it may be that
> rephrasing the speculation will be sufficient to allow posting.
> The group FAQ, which is posted on a regular basis, contains a useful
> definition of what does or does not constitute a story idea, and the
> moderator who reviewed your post may have appended specific comments.
>
> If you feel that we have bounced this post in error, you may contact
> the moderators at
b5mod-request@deepthot.org
>
>
> > [ The following text is in the "Windows-1252" character set. ]
> > [ Your display is set for the "ISO-8859-1" character set. ]
> > [ Some characters may be displayed incorrectly. ]
> >
> > > No one seems to be doing anything here, I mean, when I look at my main
> > page,
> > > for each forum that I don't usually visit it says a couple of hundred
new,
> > for
> > > "off-off topic" a couple of thousand new, and for the ones I do visit
> > about 20-30 new.
> > > For this forum it says 1 new. The last time I posted here was so long
ago
> > it's not
> > > even funny. Only conclusion, no one ever goes here.
> >
> > Yes, because there seems to be not much left to say, and because it
appears
> > that Sci-Fi has passed on the series.
> >
> >
> >
> > > Well, okay, let's talk about the movie now.
> >
> > OK, I'll try to not repeat anything that was beaten to death in January.
> >
> >
> >
> > > What did everyone think of the Hand? I mean, what would you like
> > > to have seen happen, and how do you think the alliance could beat
them.
> >
> >
> > I thought the movie should have SHOWN The Hand and their ships, say
> > in flashbacks at the archeological site, maybe via newly discovered data
> > crystals (like discovered hours ago, otherwise they could have viewed
> > them on Minbar), or archeological carvings to be translated by say
> > MAX EILERSON. After all, Max is probably working with IPX in 2265.
> > It wouldn't be any stretch at all to see him on such an important dig.
> > We should have SEEN "something" of The Hand, not just their
> > cronies. We should have SEEN the archeological site. We should
> > have SEEN remains of the probe that returned through the portal.
> > Because we didn't SEE any of this, The Hand lack credibility of threat.
> > Sure the "dirty snowflake ship" cronies were powerful, but they could be
> > making all this stuff up. They could be doing it to sound like they
have
> > these big, badass allies, but they could be lying. Without SEEING The
> > Hand, it's like a buildup to nothing, a whimper not a BANG.
> >
> > More Ranger ships should have been involved in the mission. They
> > should have gotten at least one Whitestar model done to use on the
> > mission, to make a stronger firefight and establish a level of enemy
> > ship force that we could measure against the B5 universe ships,
> > and to establish stronger visual ties to the "B5 Universe" with which
> > we're familiar. That would have helped tremendously, lending much
> > needed familiarity, and SENSE OF SCALE. The three featured ships
> > were all previously unknown, never seen before in the "B5 Universe."
> > We don't know how powerful the enemy ships are, because we don't
> > know how powerful the Valen and Liandra are. There was no known
> > BENCHMARK. Were it not for the Minbari, Narn, and Drazi characters
> > we saw, and the couple Nial fighters and Whitestars, and B5 that
> > we very briefly saw, it was almost as if the characters were in a
> > different universe, on a different show that had no connection to
> > the B5 universe.
> >
> >
> >
> > > To my understanding, the ships they fought weren't the hand, they
> > > were little crappy ones given to a slave race. So it's natural to
> > > assume that the real ones are gonna own majorly, since these
> > > already kicked a lot of ass.
> >
> > True, but we should have SEEN some of The Hand and their actual
> > ships, somehow, not fighting them in the present, but in historical
> > records.
> >
> >
> >
> > > And what of the haunted ship? The ghosts didn't go away, they
> > > just chose to shut up for the moment. Would they have done
> > > another haunted episode? And if yes, what would the possible
> > > themes be?
> >
> > Anything that gives Dulann more to do, is fine by me.
> >
> > As it was, the movie reminded me of cotton candy, looks big,
> > but there is a lot of air in there. Not much richness/complexity
> > (thread density). Strangely, this is how I felt about Crusade
> > episodes when I first saw them (in TNT's order), but Crusade had
> > a lot more visual cues from the B5 universe. "To Live and Die in
> > Starlight," didn't have nearly as many connections to the B5
> > universe. It was like the council we saw in the movie. A lot of
> > people, myself included, thought it was probably the Gray Council.
> > In all of B5, we'd only ever seen one Minbari council like that, and
> > it was the Gray Council, so it was a natural assumption, and it
> > was wrong. The question is, why try to fake out and confuse the
> > audience?
> >
> >
> > KoshN
> > ------------------------
> >
http://www.scifi.com/crusade/ http://www.b5lr.com/
> >
> > "Nothing much good on TV tonight anyway." (Captain Gideon, Babylon 5
> > Crusade - The Memory of War)