I would have to say "The Gathering". I'd heard that there was a new SF show coming, and I wanted to give it a shot, being a Trekkie from way back. (No, "Trekkie" is *not* insulting or demeaning!) Anyway, it debuted--as I remember--within weeks of DS9. As I saw it, they were pretty much the same show: there's a station in the middle of nowhere, people show up and things happen.
But Star Trek always was, and will likely continue to be, episodic in nature. Yes, Enterprise is trying to thread the season together, but it's very slow going.
However, B5 was always meant to be "a novel for television". A show with a definite beginning, middle, and--good ratings or bad--an ending. Five years long in the watching.
When I heard this, that the show would continue to weave a "story", with actual character development, I was floored, and hooked. In the UK, writing *matters*; plot and characters grow and evolve through their experiences. In the US, it's "forget last week; how do we wow them this week?" Comedy, drama, SF, doesn't matter. Ratings are everything. Hence the lack of originality being spewed across the airwaves every Autumn. Bless Dame Bona Fortuna JMS got to tell his story. The "wasteland" has an oasis, and the name of the place is Babylon 5. (Sorry, I coudn't resist. /forums/images/icons/smile.gif )
So I watched the pilot, and I liked what I saw. A murder mystery, involving people who had lives *before* this incident! They weren't...teleported...to this place, with no backstory to give the audience. Sinclair was a war hero; Dr Gaines had experience with xenobiology; Garibaldi knew his schtick, and you didn't mess with him. Notice that Lyta's tour was to introduce *the station*, not the crew.
Looking back, the writing's a bit much. Would (will?) people really speak those words in that manner? It seems a little over-the-top, if that's the phrase I'm looking for. But it was *new*, different. The approach was completely unlike anything Paramount had going for Trek. My friend taped the premier (on the pre-UPN PTEN!), and I taped every episode, in order, first time out. As well as the movies and Crusade, of course. /forums/images/icons/grin.gif And when I've the gelt, I have every intention of buying the seasonal DVDs.
As to S5's seeming lack of continuity: I hadn't heard that JMS's notes were *stolen*, and that he'd cobbled together the last season. But here's what I had heard: S4 was very nearly the last one. Ratings tanked. So the crew filmed SiL to be the last episode of *S4*, and the series, which is why it looks like it belongs more to S4 than S5. However, TNT and the fans saved the show (does it matter how S5 got airtime?) at the last minute, and so SiL was shelved for a year, to be the series' end, which is where it belongs.
Just a few tired thoughts from a tired old man. Hope I haven't bored y'all to tears!
LordRemy