December 11th, 2004
Warner Brother Features Development Department
B5: The Memory of Shadows
4000 Warner Boulevard
Burbank, CA 91522
To Whom It May Concern:
I have recently heard a disturbing rumor about the possible new Babylon 5 theatrical movie project that J. Michael Straczynski has been developing for you, THE MEMORY OF SHADOWS. I do hope the rumors are not true, and that you are not looking to recast new actors in major roles for this movie. If the original cast were to be replaced, I fear that no Babylon 5 fans, including myself, would support the film, either theatrically or on DVD.
I understand the need to bring in a wide audience, but by turning your back on the heart and soul of Babylon 5 you risk a backlash from the Babylon 5 fan-base who helped to make the series and the TV movies such a success both domestically and abroad in first-run, re-runs, and now on DVD (with over 100 million dollars in DVD sales and growing). New characters are one thing, but recasting former ones will seem outrageous to all fans, myself included. It is a step JMS has promised that he would never take...since he felt the cast deserved a pay-off for such hard work and I think that most of the fans agree with this completely.
This could be Warner Brothers' STAR TREK-type franchise, and we want to make it a major success as much as you do.
Once again, I just wanted to say if these rumors are true, I sincerely hope you will reconsider. If you don't, there won't be a Babylon 5 movie coming out: there will be what many fans would consider a shell of an imitation coming out. Please do consider the possible backlash of loyal fans on what we had hoped would be a very interesting and exciting new project to look forward to. Thank you for your time and attention.
Sincerely -
hypatia